“Waldman relates this tale in clear, unvarnished prose and it should now be considered the best narrative of its subject.” — Publishers Weekly
“Rigorous, scholarly, but accessible.” — Joe Nocera, The New York Times
“This thoughtful, accessible survey of Second Amendment law will be useful to anyone arguing either side of this endlessly controversial issue.” — Kirkus Reviews
“Waldman offers historical perspective on the fierce debate… A lively and engaging exploration.”— Booklist
“The ongoing debate about the Second Amendment and the right to bear arms continues to set off multiple explosions in the blogosphere. Waldman’s new book will not make the most zealous NRA advocates happy, but for anyone who wants his or her history of the Second Amendment straight-up, this is the most comprehensive, accessible, and compelling version of the story in print.” — Joseph J. Ellis, author of Founding Brothers
“From the founding of the Republic to the Newtown massacre and beyond, Michael Waldman vividly portrays the evolution of a nation’s passionate debate over the right to keep and bear arms. Activist, conservative justices on the U.S. Supreme Court may have thought they ended that debate in 2008, but with rich detail and crisp narrative, Waldman shows how the it continues to reverberate across the landscape with important lessons for all Americans.” — Marcia Coyle, author of The Roberts Court
“Through most of American history, the Second Amendment guaranteed the right to be a citizen-soldier, not an individual vigilante. With wit and erudition, Michael Waldman tells the story of how the Amendment’s meaning was turned upside-down and inside-out.” — David Frum, author of The Right Man: An Inside Account of the Bush White House
“Michael Waldman gives us the turbulent life story of the Second Amendment. If one clause of the Constitution better deserved a quiet retirement, it is our right to keep and bear arms, a vestige of the Founding Fathers’ concern with the role of the militia in a republican society. Yet today the Second Amendment has become one of the feistiest, most disputed clauses of the Constitution, and Waldman vividly explains why this obscure, minor provision has become so controversial.”— Jack Rakove, author of Original Meanings
“Partisan pseudo-histories of gun regulation and the Second Amendment abound. Michael Waldman’s excellent book slices through the propaganda with candor as well as scholarship. It advances an authentic and clarifying history that will surprise and enlighten citizens on all sides of the issue. Here is a smart and cogent history that performs a large public service.” — Sean Wilentz, author of The Rise of American Democracy
For the first two centuries of American history, Waldman observes, the Second Amendment received scant notice. Few people understood its provisions; scholars paid it little attention; and lawyers rarely raised it in court. But over the past four decades, it has been thrust to the center of public controversy. Politicians declare themselves its “strong supporters.” The news media bristle with reports of proposed new gun laws, or new legal challenges to them. The Second Amendment has become a synonym, in powerful unspoken ways, for America’s gun culture, and a symbol of many of the deep divisions that cleave the nation.
The Second Amendment is one awkward sentence. It reads in its entirety:
For 218 years, judges overwhelmingly concluded that the amendment simply authorized states to form militias, which we now call the National Guard. Its foggy wording and odd syntax caused lawyers and scholars to debate its puzzling commas and clauses. Then, in 2008, in the case of District of Columbia vs. Heller, an opinion of the U.S. Supreme Court written by Justice Antonin Scalia declared that the Constitution confers a right to own a gun for self-defense in the home. From that point forward, the red-hot debate over gun control and its constitutionality had to take place in this new and not at all clear legal context, as it will into the foreseeable future.
(Photo: Adrian Kinloch)
